by Denise Sullivan Denise Sullivan No Comments

The Effect Surface Finish Has on PTFE Seals

Surface finish plays an essential role in the effectiveness of PTFE seals. The different finishes provide different degrees of contact between the two components, which affects the seal’s strength and reliability. In this paper, we will discuss the effect of surface finish on PTFE seal performance and suggest ways to improve seal quality.

Surface finish on PTFE

The Influences of Surface Finish on Friction

The surface finish is critical for polymer-based seals. Despite being considered a soft plastic, PTFE is significantly harder than traditional o-ring materials. Because of this, if the mating surface is designed for other materials, it can cause the PTFE seals to leak.

As you can see in the graph below, the improvement in the surface finish has a favorable effect on the frictional force required.

The following specifications were used in the force test that resulted in the above data.

  • Stroke Speed: 4 in/min (102 mm/min)
  • Shaft Diameter: 0.1875in. (4.762mm)
  • Ambient Temperature: 73°F (23°C)
  • Mating Surface Material: 17 -4 PH S.S.
  • Mating Surface Hardness: -40 Rc

Surface Finish Influences on Wear

The finish of the mating surface is one of the main factors in the PTFE seal wear. Wear on the seal is generally proportional to frictional force. In other words, less friction reduces the wear on the seal. 

The following graph shows how a smoother surface finish reduces the PTFE seal wear rate.

To calculate the wear rate in microinches RMS, we used the formula IN3 -MIN/LB-FT-HR -10-9. For microinches Ra, we used the formula CM3 -MIN/KG-M-HR -10-9.

We used the following test parameters during our testing to ensure accuracy for each test.

  • Surface Speed: 55 fpm (17 m/min)
  • Loading Stress: 55 lb./in2 (4 bar)
  • Wear Rate in Air: @ PV 3025 lb./in2 x ft/min (7.5 N/mm x m/min)
  • Mating Surface Hardness: Rc 42
  • Matin Surface Maerial 17 -4 PH Stainless steal
  • Mating Surface Finish: 1.6 to 111.1 microinches RMS (1.4 to 100 microinches RA)
  • Ambient Temperature: 70°F (21°C)
  • Ambient Relative Humidity 75% RH
  • Duration 5 Hours
  • Seal material FP

Influences on Sealing Ability

Finally, we looked at how the surface finish affected PTFE’s sealing ability. In general, the sealing ability of PTFE is proportional to the fluid’s viscosity. If a media, like gas, has a reduced viscosity, it is more difficult to seal. In these situations, having a smoother finish on the mating surface can help ensure fewer leaks.

We’ve found that different mediums require not only different finish ranges between them but also different finish ranges when considering if the surface is dynamic or static. You can see our suggested finish in the table below.

MediaDynamic Surface Static Surface 
Gases and Liquids at Cryogenic Temperatures2 to 4 microinches RMS
(1.8 to 3.6 Microinches Ra)		4 to 8 Microinches RMS
(3.6 to 7.2 Microinches Ra)
Gas at Non-Cryogenic Temperatures6 to 12 Microinches RMS
(5.4 to 10.8 Microinches Ra)		12 to 32 Microinches RMS
(10.8 to 28.8 Microinches Ra)
Liquids8 to 16 Microinches RMS
(7.2 to 14.4 Microinches Ra)		16 to 32 Microinches RMS
(14.4 to 28.8 Microinches Ra)

As you can see, the mating surface finishes can profoundly affect PTFE seals. Because of this, if the mating surface is designed for other materials, it can cause the PTFE seals to leak. Finally, we examined how this affected PTFE’s sealing ability. In general, the sealing ability of PTFE is proportional to the fluid’s viscosity. 

by Denise Sullivan Denise Sullivan No Comments

Rotary Shaft Mating Surfaces: What You Need to Know

 

rotary shaft mating surfaces

Rotary seals are essential to maintaining the life of the equipment. While choosing the appropriate rotary seal materials, the rotary shaft mating surfaces are equally important. 

Below, we will discuss rotary seals, materials used for seals, and rotary shaft properties.

Rotary Seals

Rotary seals work to help keep the system lubricated while excluding contaminates. A properly fitting seal can positively impact the life of the lubricant. Oil’s life span at 86°F (30°C) is 30 years. However, as the oil heats up, the life span diminishes rapidly to no more than a 30-day life span.

The addition of contaminants and water also limits the life of the oil and the ball bearings. For example, adding .002% water into the oil lubricant will reduce the ball bearing’s life by 50%. The cause of the ball-bearing integrity loss is called hydrogen embrittlement.

Common Materials Used for Rotary Seals

Rotary seals come in several different materials. The optimal choice is dependent on the environment in which it is used. The most common materials include nitrile rubber, polyacrylate rubber, fluoroelastomers (FKM), and PTFE.

While these materials are a good choice for rotary seals, conventional rubber seals are common in static applications where temperature and chemical compatibility are not a concern. PTFE is the solution in high-speed dynamic service requiring low friction seals or where exposure to severe temperature or chemicals exists. There are different types of PTFE used for rotary shaft seals.  Users can choose from 

  • Virgin PTFE
  • Molybdenum Disulfide Filled PTFE (MoS2)
  • Carbon Filled PTFE
  • Carbon and Graphite Filled PTFE
  • Carbon and MoS2  Filled PTFE
  • Glass Filled PTFE
  • Glass and MoS2  Filled PTFE
  • Polymide Filled PTFE

Properties of Rotary Shafts Mating Surfaces That Affect Sealing Performance

Most often, rotary shafts are metal. However, the rotary shaft mating surface could be made from plastics. No matter what material the shaft is made from, some properties will affect the sealing performance of the shaft.

The properties of the rotary shaft that affect sealing performance are the shaft harness and the shaft roughness. The sections below explain in greater detail how the hardness and roughness of the rotary shaft can affect the rotary shaft’s sealing performance. 

Rotary Shaft Hardness

The hardness of the rotary shaft is how deep an indenter can penetrate the surface of a shaft. The shaft’s hardness is measured in the Rockwell C scale. The higher the number, the more complex the surface. 

As a general rule, the rotary shaft should always be harder than the seal to ensure the seal wears out before the shaft. Additionally, if you choose a harder surface, there are more options for seal materials.

With a rotary shaft with a hardness exceeding 45 Rockwell C, the seal doesn’t have time to polish and “bed in.” That means that any roughness on the surface will cause issues with the seal, wearing it down quicker than average. A shaft with a hardness under 45 Rc requires a softer seal which doesn’t have as long of a life.

The choice of hardness depends on the environmental pressure and shaft speed. For example:

  • In environments of 1000 psi with rates up to 150 sfpm, a shaft with 70Rc or greater is necessary
  • Settings using shaft speed 2500 sfpm and 0 psi need a hardness of 60Rc or greater.
  • Rotary shaft speeds of up to 150 sfpm and 0 psi need a hardness of at least 35Rc, with lubrication, or 44, with no lubrication.

Rotary Shaft Mating Surface Roughness

The rotary shaft’s roughness refers to the shaft surface’s unevenness. To measure the roughness, measurements of high and low points of the shaft and taking the difference to determine the machined tolerance.

Ideally, a smoother surface will increase the seal life and offer outstanding performance. But on the other hand, when the surface is exceptionally smooth, there is no way for the oil to flow between the mating surface and the seal. As a result, the seal wears out quicker without lubricant between the seal and the mating surface.

Of course, a high roughness level can allow leaks through low points on the shaft. Therefore, the rotary shaft roughness needs to be relatively smooth but not so smooth that the seal cannot be lubricated.

Rotary shafts work with the rotary seals to keep lubrication from dirt and water. Understanding the properties of the rotary shaft mating surfaces helps determine the type of seal material chosen. Contact us today for your rotary seal and shaft mating needs.