Pressure cycling and pulsation can lead to seal issues like extrusion, blow-by, and fatigue damage. There are, however, some design principles that can address these issues and mitigate their effects. This article takes a look at the issues related to cycling and pulsation and addresses six key design considerations related to them.
Pressure Cycling and Pulsation
Pressure cycling refers to repeated transitions between low and high pressure, including dwell time at each level. Pulsation, on the other hand, is associated with high-frequency pressure oscillations superimposed on the mean system pressure (often pump- or compressor-driven). Pressure spikes are short-duration transients that exceed nominal operating pressure.
Designing polymer seals for cyclic pressure and pulsation is actually a system-level problem. Consideration must go into the material, energization method, gland geometry, hardware stiffness, surface finish, and validation testing.
Seal Issues Related to Pressure Cycling and Pulsation
When polymer seals are subject to pressure cycling and pulsation, the primary design objective becomes the ability to maintain adequate contact stress and sealing integrity throughout the entire pressure waveform while avoiding extrusion, blow-by, and fatigue damage.
Extrusion occurs when the seal is forced into a clearance gap by pressure, like a soft solid getting pushed into a narrow crack. Blow-by takes place when a pressurized fluid or gas leaks past the seal because there is not enough contact stress. Fatigue damage is the progressive cracking or material breakdown that is caused by repeated loading cycles. Note that each individual cycle can be below the material’s one-time strength limit and still result in fatigue damage.
Signs of Pressure Cycling and Pulsation Issues
There are several signs that pressure cycling and pulsation are causing problems. One of the first is early leakage after a very short run-in period. The seal might also experience intermittent leakage that is related to the duty cycle or pump frequency. Another sign of seal problems is the extrusion of the gear lip, torn edges, or nibbling. Finally, backup ring displacement or seal rotation can also be a signal of issues.
These problems usually show up in hydraulic actuators, pumps, and manifolds, gas compression stage and valve plates, chemical processing skids with pulsation dampeners, and high-cycle test equipment and aerospace pneumatic systems.
Design Tips for Addressing Pressure Issues
Here are some design tips for working with seals undergoing pressure cycling.
Pressure Waveform
In order to mitigate issues with pressure cycling and pulsation, it is important to look at the pressure waveform and not just the peak pressure. For example, document mean pressure, peak pressure, minimum pressure, ramp rate, frequency, and dwell times. Then identify the transient spikes separately from the steady cycles. Once this information has been gathered, map the waveform to the duty cycle and the total number of cycles.
Polymer
Remember to select the polymer family for the seal based on cyclic strength and creep resistance. Filled PTFE offers good creep resistance and extrusion margin. PEEK and PPS options can lead to a higher modulus, better load retention, and improved wear. UHMW-PE offers low friction but lower stiffness. However, keep in mind that the material choice should also be considered with regard to the temperature, media, PV, and allowable deformation.
Spring-Energized Seals
Another excellent option is to utilize spring-energized seals to maintain contact stress when system pressure drops. These seals have pressure-energized lips designed to avoid issues during pressure reversals. In addition, consider the use of dual-acting geometries for bidirectional pressure. And avoid relying solely on squeeze for long-life high-cycle conditions when relaxation is expected.
Seal Gland
When designing the gland, it is important to ensure that the seal is both well-supported and deforms in a controlled manner when subjected to pressure cycling. The compressive fa orce should provide reliable initial sealing force without being so high that excessive creep results over time. Utilize radii and lead-in chamfers to eliminate sharp edges that can result in problematic notches or tears. And when clearances cannot be held tightly, use anti-extrusion features to ensure the pressure cannot force the polymer into a gap.
Backup Ring
Another potential aspect of the design is the use of a backup ring. Its material should be fully compatible with the primary seal and can maintain strength and dimensional stability across the operating temperature range. When deciding between split or solid design backup rings, keep in mind potential issues with rotation and migration during pressure pulsation.
Surface Finish
Under pressure cycling, the surface and interface details matter significantly. Small leak paths are the potential problems here, and can be addressed. First, the counterface roughness should result in a surface that supports film formation but does not lead to bypass channels or issues with abrasive wear. The lay direction should prevent machining grooves from behaving as micropumps during pressure fluctuations. In addition, if there is a possibility that erosion, wear, or corrosion could affect the roughness over time, use coatings or surface treatment that will stabilize the counterface.
Conclusion
Pressure cycling and pulsation can cause extrusion, blow-by, and fatigue damage. Careful design, however, can mitigate these issues.
If you are working on a seal design that must provide reliable performance when subject to pressure cycling and pulsation, let the polymer seal experts at Advanced EMC help. Contact us today.
